Remington 870 vs Benelli Nova - Which Shotgun Should I Choose?

Looking for the Best Shotgun Choice

I’m currently on the hunt for a new shotgun and have narrowed it down to two solid options: the Remington 870 and the Benelli Nova. I’ve done some research, but I’d love to hear from those who have hands-on experience with these guns since I’m trying to make an informed decision.

Key Considerations

Here are some specific areas I’m hoping to get insights on:

  • Handling: How do these shotguns feel in your hands? Is one more comfortable than the other?
  • Recoil Management: I’d like to hear about how each model manages recoil, especially if you’ve used them in a variety of loads.
  • Safety Features: What safety features should I be aware of? Any personal experiences you can share?
  • Purpose: I’m considering them for both home defense and hunting. Are either of these shotguns particularly better for one of those uses?

Additional Thoughts

Personal experiences make a huge difference in understanding the real-world performance of firearms, so any real-life stories or detailed evaluations would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you so much for sharing your insights! Looking forward to your replies.

7 Likes

I’ve had experience with both shotguns. The Remington 870 is known for its reliability and smooth action, especially for hunting. The Benelli Nova, on the other hand, is super lightweight and great for tactical scenarios. It really depends on what you’re looking for!

That’s a great point! I’ve found the accuracy with the Benelli Nova to be impressive, especially when shooting clays. It feels very balanced in the hands.

Ive always preferred the Remington 870 for its classic feel and customizable options. It can be a bit heavier, but that helps with stability when aiming.

4 Likes

That’s true! The 870’s customizability is a huge plus, but the Benelli Nova’s ease of use for quick follow-up shots is phenomenal too.

For hunting, I’ve always gone with the Remington 870. It’s simply dependable, but if I were in a tactical situation, I would definitely choose the Benelli Nova for its quicker reload time.

That’s a solid perspective! What about recoil? I’ve heard mixed reviews on how the two handle it.

The Benelli Nova has a recoil-reducing system that I found very impressive during clay shooting. It made the experience much more enjoyable than I expected!

Interesting! I’d like to know if anyone has had experience with both in a tactical training setting.

I’ve used both in tactical drills, and honestly, the 870 felt more traditional, while the Nova was just faster to operate. It’s all about personal preference and use case.

Great insights! Does anyone have thoughts about how each performs in wet conditions? That’s always a concern for me.

In my experience, the Remington 870 holds up well in wet conditions, especially if you keep it maintained. The Nova is also very durable, being polymer, but I trust the 870 more when it pours!

Sounds like both have their merits. If I had a nickel for every debate about these shotguns, I’d probably need a bigger safe!

Haha! That’s so true, jmichael! I’ve thought about getting both just to have options! But really, it’s all about what fits your lifestyle the best.

I’ve had experience with both shotguns. The Remington 870 is known for its solid construction using steel components which adds to its durability. The Benelli Nova, on the other hand, uses a polymer stock that is lighter but may not feel as rugged.

That’s interesting! I’ve read that the Benelli Nova is designed for easy cleaning, but how does that compare to the 870’s maintenance requirements?

The Benelli Nova is very easy to maintain because of its simple design and fewer parts. The 870 is durable but can require more thorough upkeep, especially if it sees a lot of use.

That sounds convincing! But how do the two stacks compare in terms of long-term reliability?

3 Likes

In terms of long-term reliability, the Remington 870 has a track record that’s hard to beat. Many users report thousands of rounds with minimal issues, which is a big plus for me.

6 Likes

I’ve heard that too! Are there specific conditions where either shotgun excels in durability?