Looking for the Best Holster for Model 19 Carry Comp?

General
1

I’m on the hunt for the perfect holster for my Smith & Wesson Model 19 Carry Comp and could really use some input from the community! Here’s what I’m looking for:

Key Considerations:

  • Concealment: Since I plan on using it for everyday carry, the holster should allow for good concealment without sacrificing comfort.
  • Comfort: I’d love to hear about any options that you have found particularly comfortable, especially for long periods of wear.
  • Design: Any recommendations on holsters that have intuitive designs for easy access would be appreciated.
  • Compatibility: Are there specific brands or models that you’ve tried and found to work well with the Model 19 Carry Comp?

Questions to Consider:

  • What are your go-to holsters for this revolver?
  • Any specific features that you find indispensable in a holster?
  • Would you recommend OWB (Outside the Waistband) or IWB (Inside the Waistband) options, and why?

Looking forward to hearing your experiences and suggestions! Thanks in advance!

2

I’m using a bladetech holster with my Model 19 Carry Comp, and it’s been fantastic for concealed carry. It hugs my body well, especially with fitted clothes. Very minimal printing.

7 Likes
3

I tried a Galco Inside the Waistband holster and found it extremely comfortable for range shooting. It feels secure and doesn’t shift while moving.

8 Likes
4

I’ve been searching for something that fits with athletic wear. Does anyone have experience with holsters that work well for that? Might need to switch it up!

5

I hear you! I have a Crossbreed Supertuck that works great, even with a tighter fit. Just make sure to adjust it properly!

6

For everyday carry, I prefer a level 2 retention holster. It may not be ideal for concealed carry, but it gives me peace of mind during my range sessions!

7

Anyone else experience chafing after a few hours wearing their holster? I enjoy wearing a ‘tactical’ shirt but sometimes wish it was more comfortable!

8

Chafing is the bane of my existence! I switched to a softer material holster and it’s made a huge difference.

9

I find that my Kydex holster is great for the range but can be a bit uncomfortable for long periods. I often worry about the print when wearing a hoodie.

5 Likes
10

That’s been my experience too! A good cover garment helps minimize printing.

11

I’m currently using a shoulder holster for my Model 19 Carry Comp, but I’ve heard mixed reviews. Curious if I should stick to the waist or give it a shot!

4 Likes
12

Shoulder can be comfortable if you find the right fit! Just watch out for quick draws. Anyone have a recommendation?

13

Just remember, the holster that works for one body type may not work for another. Always test a few before making a decision – it’s like dating! Keep swiping! :joy:

14

I’ve been using a holster that has a retention adjustment feature, and it holds my Model 19 Carry Comp securely, even during movement. Highly recommend checking out holsters with adjustable retention.

15

I agree! Retention is key. I have a one with a locking mechanism and it hasn’t failed me in any situation.

16

Finding a holster with a good balance of retention and ease of draw is essential. A snug fit really helps during high-stress scenarios. Anyone tried Kydex options?

17

Yes! Kydex has been a game-changer for me. Super secure and easy to reholster when I need to.

18

I’m looking at several holsters right now. Can anyone comment on their experience with retention while jogging or moving a lot? I need something reliable.

19

I’ve jogged with my holster and it stayed in place, but I think the fit is crucial. A little too loose could be problematic.

20

Are there any holsters that come with both retention and a smooth draw? I feel like some designs focus too much on one or the other.