Blackhorn 209 vs Pyrodex: Which is Best for Muzzleloading?

Ammunition & Reloading
1

Introduction

I’m looking to dive into a detailed comparison between Blackhorn 209 and Pyrodex, specifically in the context of their use as propellants for muzzleloading firearms. Both of these powders have their advocates, and I’m curious to gather insights from fellow shooters and hunters who have experience with these two options.

Blackhorn 209

Blackhorn 209 is known for its unique properties. Here are some key aspects to consider:

  • Performance: It offers consistent ignition and a high energy output, making it a favorite for those aiming for precision.
  • Velocity: Shooters often report higher velocities compared to traditional black powders, which can be beneficial for both hunting and target shooting.
  • Cleaning: One of the standout features of Blackhorn 209 is how easy it is to clean after use. It doesn’t create the same level of fouling, which could save you time at the range or after a hunting trip.
  • Cost: It is generally more expensive than traditional powders, so I’d love to hear if people find the price worth it for the performance benefits.

Pyrodex

On the flip side, Pyrodex has been a staple in the muzzleloading community for years:

  • Versatility: Pyrodex comes in several variations, catering to different shooting styles and needs.
  • Energy Output: While it may not match Blackhorn 209 in terms of high velocities, many shooters enjoy its reliable performance.
  • Cleaning: Pyrodex can be messier and requires more effort to clean after use compared to Blackhorn 209.
  • Cost Effectiveness: It’s usually cheaper, which could be a significant factor for those who shoot regularly.

What I’m Looking For

I would really appreciate hearing personal experiences with both powders. Specifically:

  • What performance differences have you noticed in accuracy and range?
  • How has each powder impacted your cleaning routine?
  • Is the cost of Blackhorn 209 justified by your results?

Your feedback could really help me make an informed decision and also help others who are in the same boat. Thanks in advance for any insights!

5 Likes
2

I’ve always found Blackhorn 209 to be superior in terms of burn rate. It ignites more consistently compared to Pyrodex, particularly in colder weather.

3 Likes
3

That’s interesting! What scenarios have you used it in? Hunting or just target shooting?

4

I prefer Pyrodex for hunting. It does have a slower burn rate, but I feel it provides a solid punch when it comes to energy output for game.

5

That’s a good point! Pyrodex does have a history of reliable performance. Have you noticed any specific benefits when using it in the field?

6

Honestly, I switch between both depending on my needs. For target shooting, Blackhorn 209 feels like the better choice because of its cleanliness.

7

Support for Blackhorn comes from its higher efficiency; shooters often report less fouling. This makes cleanup much easier, especially after a long day of shooting.

8

Yes! Plus, it’s great for those who shoot a lot. I’ve had fewer issues with jamming or misfires using it.

1 Like
9

I’ve heard mixed things about Pyrodex’s moisture sensitivity. Is that a big detractor for you guys using it?

10

That’s one concern for me. Blackhorn 209 is more reliable in wet conditions, but I still like Pyrodex for the nostalgia factor!

6 Likes
11

Totally! I love the old-school feel of Pyrodex, but I guess performance comes first!

2 Likes
12

I’m curious about the price differences too. Is Blackhorn 209 significantly more expensive than Pyrodex?

13

Price can vary, but generally, yes, Blackhorn 209 is pricier. However, some claim the performance justifies the cost.

14

That’s worth considering. Sometimes a higher upfront cost can save you more in the long run with fewer failures.

7 Likes
15

I just think the debate is funny. It’s like Coke vs Pepsi! Different shooters, different tastes.

16

I’m curious about how Blackhorn 209 performs in flintlocks. Has anyone tried it a lot with those? I usually stick with Pyrodex for my older firearms.

2 Likes
17

I’ve found that Blackhorn works best in modern inline rifles. The burn characteristics are so different from Pyrodex that it can get tricky in older models.

18

For anyone using Blackhorn, cleaning can be a pain! The residue seems tougher than Pyrodex. I suggest a good cleaning kit for the residue.

2 Likes
19

True! I use a special cleaner designed for Blackhorn. It makes the job way easier compared to standard solvents.

8 Likes
20

My experience with loading techniques shows that Pyrodex requires a different approach, especially with wad usage! Has anyone experimented with wads in conjunction with Blackhorn?