Anyone Have Experience with .45-70 Snub Nose Revolvers?

I’m really interested in the .45-70 caliber snub-nose revolvers, particularly the Magnum Research ‘Thunder Snub’ model. I’ve heard varying opinions about its performance and usability for shooting and hunting.

Ballistics and Performance

From what I understand, the .45-70 is quite a powerful round, and I’m curious how this translates into a snub-nose revolver.

  • Recoil: How does the recoil feel when firing these? Is it manageable or too intense?
  • Accuracy: For a snub-nose, what’s the effective range? Can it hold its own against longer barrels?
  • Stopping Power: I’ve read that the .45-70 has substantial stopping power, but does that hold true in a snub configuration?

Features and Comparisons

I’d love to know if there are specific features you find valuable in the Thunder Snub that might elevate it over other revolver options. Also, how does it compare to traditional .45 revolvers?

  • Weight: Is it too heavy for everyday carry?
  • Sight options: What sighting systems work best with it?

Recommendations

Lastly, for those who’ve had hands-on experience, would you recommend this model for someone looking for a versatile revolver? Any issues or concerns you encountered?

I’d appreciate any insights on these questions or any additional information that could help me decide if this is the right purchase for me. Thanks in advance!

I’ve had some experience with the .45-70 snub nose revolvers, particularly the Taurus Raging Bull. It’s a beast! The heavy frame helps with recoil management. Keep an eye on the trigger pull. It’s not the smoothest.

3 Likes

How do you find the weight on that model for carry? I’ve heard it’s quite hefty!

5 Likes

I think the Ruger Alaskan is another solid option. It’s compact and has a good reputation for reliability. Perfect for bear country if you’re looking for something powerful.

I’ve been eyeing the Smith & Wesson Model 629 as well. It’s not traditionally snub-nosed, but for a good balance of power and usability, it might fit the bill. What do you all think?

3 Likes

Ruger does make a mean firearm! Is there a specific caliber that you recommend for first-time .45-70 users?

3 Likes

For newcomers, I’d suggest looking into lower power loads initially. The .45-70 can be a handful! That gives you a chance to get familiar with handling before moving to full power rounds.

Snub-nose revolvers can be tricky due to their short barrel lengths but, the compact size is definitely a plus for concealability. Just make sure you’re honing your shooting skills!

5 Likes

Great advice! What brands should someone start looking at for these types of rounds?

You might want to try Federal or Hornady for good quality .45-70 cartridges. They’re generally well-reviewed and offer a range of loads. You definitely don’t want to skimp on ammo!

I keep imagining carrying one of these snubs around, and it feels like a scene from an action movie! But in all seriousness, it’s crucial to practice regularly to stay proficient.

I have a .45-70 snub nose and the key to maintaining it is regular cleaning. Use a bore snake to remove debris after each use. A light oil on the cylinder helps prevent rust.

2 Likes

Great tip! What kind of oil do you recommend for the cylinder? I’ve been using CLP, not sure if that’s the best.

I usually go with a good gun oil that offers corrosion resistance. CLP is okay, but a dedicated gun oil might give you better results over time!

I’ve heard that too! How often do you all clean your snub nose? After every outing or less frequent?

1 Like

I clean mine after every session. It just keeps everything in tip-top shape. Plus, nothing beats the feeling of a freshly cleaned firearm! :dart:

6 Likes

Exactly, routine cleaning is essential for longevity. Also, remember to check the ejector and springs regularly – they can wear out even with minimal use.

Good point! Is there a way to safely store these revolvers that prolongs their life?

2 Likes

Store them in a climate-controlled room and use a dehumidifier if needed. Also, a soft case can prevent scratches while allowing airflow.

I never thought about airflow! Do you think silicone socks are worth using for these revolvers?