460 S&W vs 500 S&W: Which Should I Choose for Hunting?

Hunting with Firearms
1

When considering powerful handguns for hunting, the debate between the .460 S&W and the .500 S&W often comes up. Both of these cartridges are known for their impressive ballistics and stopping power, but they have different characteristics that make them suitable for various hunting scenarios.

Overview of Each Cartridge

  • .460 S&W: This cartridge was designed to be versatile, capable of shooting a wide range of bullet weights ranging from 200 to 400 grains. It’s known for its flat trajectory and high velocity, making it suitable for medium to large game at longer distances.
  • .500 S&W: Generally regarded as one of the most powerful handgun cartridges available, the .500 S&W is designed primarily for big game. It typically fires heavier bullets, around 300 to 700 grains, with exceptional energy and stopping power.

Ballistics Comparison

  • Velocity: The .460 S&W usually outperforms the .500 in terms of velocity, especially with lighter bullets. This can be an advantage for hunting faster-moving game or when shots might be taken at longer distances.
  • Energy: The .500 S&W surpasses the .460 in energy, particularly with heavier bullets. This makes it a better choice for hunting very large game like bear or moose, where significant stopping power is critical.

Suitability for Game

  • Medium Game: If you’re planning to hunt deer or similar-sized animals, the .460 S&W provides enough power, versatility, and manageable recoil for effective shots.
  • Large Game: For larger animals, the .500 S&W clearly shines. Its power not only ensures a clean and effective kill but also reduces the chances of an animal being able to escape after a hit.

Recoil Considerations

  • Recoil: The .500 S&W can be quite punishing due to its high power, which might not be suitable for all shooters. The .460 S&W, while also having significant recoil, is generally considered easier to handle, making it a better choice for those who prefer a more manageable shooting experience.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, the decision between the .460 S&W and .500 S&W boils down to your intended use. If you plan on hunting a wider variety of game and want a cartridge that’s versatile and easier to shoot, the .460 might be your best bet. However, if your focus is primarily on taking down big game with absolute authority, the .500 is hard to beat.

I’m eager to hear everyone’s thoughts and experiences with these cartridges. Has anyone done a side-by-side comparison at the range, or have you taken either one on a hunt? Let’s discuss!

2

I’ve shot both, and the recoil on the 500 S&W can be brutal. It definitely affects accuracy for follow-up shots! The 460 S&W is more manageable for most shooters.

3 Likes
3

Exactly! I think it allows for better accuracy overall, especially if you’re hunting where follow-up shots are crucial.

7 Likes
4

Managing recoil is a big issue, though. Proper stance and grip can make a significant difference. I found using a muzzle brake on the 500 helps a lot!

8 Likes
5

Totally agree! Plus, working on your breathing technique is key to handling that punch.

6

I have to say, the recoil from the 500 S&W makes it less appealing for long sessions at the range. I start flinching after a few rounds, affecting my accuracy.

3 Likes
7

Exactly! Managing that flinch is crucial. The 460 gives you a fighting chance to stay steady.

8

Does anyone else find the 500 too heavy for extended hunts? Even with proper tools, it gets tiring quickly, which adds to the challenge.

9

It’s definitely hefty! But for me, that power is worth the extra weight. Still, managing recoil should be a priority.

10

I’ve also wondered if going with the lighter 460 S&W could help prevent some of those recoil-induced accuracy issues. Has it worked for anyone here?

11

Absolutely! Less recoil helps maintain focus on target and improves shot placement.

12

Over time you can get used to the 500’s recoil, but it does take training. Such a commitment! Any tips for beginners?

13

Start with lighter loads and work your way up. And remember, practice makes a difference in handling recoil!

14

It feels a bit like a rodeo when you first try the 500! I had to learn to roll with the punch, but it was a fun challenge!

15

I’ve been researching the availability of ammo for both calibers. The 460 S&W is generally easier to find and is a bit cheaper compared to the 500 S&W. This can really impact your practice time and overall shooting experience.

16

That’s true! I’ve found that while the 460 price varies, the 500 can be quite steep, which definitely limits practice sessions. It’s something to consider if you want to shoot more.

17

Absolutely, I had a friend who gave up on 500 S&W because of the ammo cost. The last time I checked, 500 S&W went for double the price of 460 S&W. That’s no small factor when planning your hunting trips.

18

I’ve heard that for the 500 S&W, you can actually reload your own ammo, which might bring the cost down. Is that a route anyone here has considered?

19

I haven’t reloaded myself, but I know many who say it’s worth it. The initial investment can be steep, but in the long run, it can save you money if you shoot frequently.

7 Likes
20

One thing I love about the 460 S&W is that it can shoot .454 Casull rounds. This makes ammo availability even better. It really opens up practice opportunities without breaking the bank.