4570 vs 450 Bushmaster - Which One Should I Choose for Hunting?

Hunting with Firearms
1

Introduction

I’ve been doing some research on two popular cartridges: the .45-70 and .450 Bushmaster. Both seem great for hunting, but I’m trying to figure out which one would be best suited for my needs.

Overview of Each Cartridge

  • .45-70: This cartridge has a long history and is known for its effectiveness, especially for larger game. It packs a punch and is often favored for its stopping power. A traditional choice, often associated with lever-action rifles.
  • .450 Bushmaster: This round is newer and was designed with modern rifles in mind. It provides similar stopping power within a shorter range and is often used for hunting in thicker brush where shots might be taken at under 200 yards.

Key Differences

  1. Ballistics:

    • The .45-70 typically has a flatter trajectory at longer ranges due to its heavier bullet weight.
    • The .450 Bushmaster has a more pronounced drop over longer distances but is easier to shoot with less recoil.

  2. Recoil:

    • The recoil from the .45-70 can be quite significant, especially in lighter rifles.
    • The .450 Bushmaster is generally noted for its manageable recoil, making it more comfortable for multiple shots.

  3. Rifle Compatibility:

    • The .45-70 is usually found in traditional lever-action or single-shot rifles.
    • The .450 Bushmaster is more commonly chambered in AR-15 style rifles, which might be appealing for those who prefer modern platforms.

Selecting the Right Cartridge for Your Needs

  • If you’re targeting larger game at longer distances and have a solid recoil tolerance, the .45-70 might be your best bet.
  • For shorter ranges, especially in thick cover, the .450 Bushmaster could offer advantages due to rapid follow-up shots and versatile platform options.

Conclusion

Ultimately, choosing between the .4570 and the .450 Bushmaster depends on your hunting style and the environments you typically hunt in. I’d love to hear from anyone who has experience with either cartridge. What do you prefer, and why? Any insights into performance would be really helpful as I make my decision.

Looking forward to hearing your thoughts!

2

I’m leaning towards the .450 Bushmaster for hunting. It has less recoil than the .4570, making it easier to shoot accurately for follow-up shots.

1 Like
3

But the .4570 delivers more energy on impact, which is crucial for larger game. It really depends on what you’re hunting!

4

Both cartridges have their pros and cons. The .450 Bushmaster typically has a flatter trajectory at close ranges, but the .4570 has a longer history in deer hunting.

4 Likes
5

That’s true! I actually enjoy using the .4570 for its powerful punch, especially on bigger game like elk.

3 Likes
6

In terms of effective range, the .450 Bushmaster excels up to 200 yards, while the .4570 can confidently reach out to 250+ yards with the right load.

7

Interesting! I’ve found that the .450 can be really effective with a good scope, even at those ranges. How are you guys feeling about recoil?

8

Recoil is definitely a factor! The .4570 has a reputation for being a bit harsher. It might be a concern for some shooters, particularly if you’re not used to it.

8 Likes
9

I love the kick of the .4570! It’s part of the thrill for me. Plus, nothing compares to the satisfaction of seeing a clean shot on a deer at a distance.

7 Likes
10

For target shooting, I prefer the .450 Bushmaster’s lighter recoil. It’s a lot more enjoyable for a day at the range without feeling beat up after a few rounds.

11

Agreed! But I’m curious, does anyone think the .450 Bushmaster can match the .4570 in hunting scenarios, despite its drawbacks?

12

You have a point, but the .450’s versatility is impressive too, especially with a variety of bullet options. It’s not as powerful, but it gets the job done for many.

13

True! It’s all about finding what works for your hunting style. Can’t go wrong with either choice!

14

I’ve been considering the .4570 for its power. Have you looked at the Marlin 1895? Great for that caliber!

4 Likes
15

The .450 Bushmaster is no slouch either! Check out the Ruger American Rifle in .450. It’s lightweight and very accurate.

16

Anyone tried both? I’m torn between the two for deer hunting, especially since I often hunt in thick woods.

17

The .450 Bushmaster is fantastic for dense forests due to its shorter range. A friend swears by the Remington Ammo for better expansion on impact.

18

I’ve heard good things about Hornady, too! They have a great lineup for both cartridges.

7 Likes
19

I prefer the .4570 for its historic feel and raw power! The ammo can get pricey, though. Just food for thought.

20

Haha, ‘raw power’ sounds enticing! But what’s the recoil like on the .4570 compared to the .450? Maybe we should consider that.